The Lost Feed

🌐Old Internet

Inside the Heroku Exodus: Where Developers Really Went Next

Discover the untold stories of developers migrating off Heroku. Learn about the challenges, the surprising alternatives, and the true costs involved.

14 views·5 min read·Jul 8, 2026
Ask HN: So you moved off Heroku, where did you go?

For a long time, Heroku was the go-to place for many developers. It was easy to use, letting people launch their apps without much fuss. It felt like a simple, friendly cloud where ideas could quickly become real.

Then, things changed. The platform announced significant price adjustments, and suddenly, many developers found themselves needing to find a new home for their projects. It was a big moment, forcing a lot of people to rethink how they hosted their applications.

The Great Heroku Shift: Why Developers Started Looking Elsewhere

When Heroku announced its new pricing, it sent ripples through the developer community. What was once a budget-friendly option, especially for smaller projects and startups, became much more expensive for many. This change meant that thousands of applications needed to move.

Developers, from those running personal side projects to teams managing business-critical services, had to consider their options. The main goal for most was to find a new platform that offered a better balance of cost and control, without sacrificing too much ease of use.

Asking the Big Questions: Where Do You Go From Here?

The sudden need to move sparked a massive conversation. People wanted to know where others were going and what their experiences were like. It wasn't just about picking the cheapest option, but about finding a sustainable place for their apps.

Many developers wondered if they should stick with a similar easy-to-use platform (known as PaaS, or Platform as a Service) or move to something more hands-on (like IaaS, Infrastructure as a Service). This choice often came down to how much technical skill they had and how much time they wanted to spend managing servers.

The Migration Marathon: More Work Than You Think

Moving an application is rarely as simple as copying files. Many developers found that migrating off Heroku was a significant undertaking. For some, it meant rewriting parts of their code to fit new environments.

One common observation was that the amount of work depended heavily on the app's complexity. A small, simple app might take a few days, while larger, more complex systems could demand weeks or even months of effort from a team. It often required learning about new deployment methods and database setups.

"We thought it would be a quick move, but it turned into a deep lesson in cloud architecture," one developer noted, summarizing a common feeling.

Different Apps, Different Efforts

Consider the variety of apps people moved: some had tiny apps getting a few hits a month, others managed medium-sized apps with thousands of daily users, and a few handled large systems with millions of hits. Each type presented its own set of challenges.

For smaller apps, the goal was often to find a truly free or very cheap solution. For bigger apps, reliability and scalability became the main concerns, often requiring more advanced cloud knowledge.

From Heroku User to Cloud Explorer: The Learning Curve

Before the shift, many developers relied on Heroku's simplicity. Their entire experience with deploying apps might have been limited to Heroku's straightforward commands. The migration forced a lot of people to expand their technical knowledge.

Moving often meant learning new concepts like:

  • Containerization (using Docker)

  • Server management (even basic virtual machines)

  • Database hosting on different providers

  • Setting up continuous deployment pipelines

This learning, while sometimes frustrating, was incredibly valuable. It turned many Heroku-only users into more well-rounded cloud professionals, giving them a deeper understanding of how their applications truly run.

Counting the Pennies: The Real Cost Comparison

One of the biggest drivers for moving was cost, and developers eagerly compared prices. The hope was always to save money, and often, they did. Many reported significant savings, especially for apps that had grown expensive on Heroku.

However, the cost comparison wasn't always straightforward. While the raw hosting price might be lower on a new platform, developers sometimes overlooked the hidden costs of time and effort. Managing servers, troubleshooting issues, and setting up new systems all took valuable developer hours.

Some found that while their monthly bill went down, their team's time spent on operations went up. It was a trade-off, but for many, the overall savings and increased control made it worthwhile.

A New Home for Every App: Matching Solutions to Needs

Developers moved their apps to a wide array of new homes. The choice often depended on the app's programming language (like Python with Django, Ruby on Rails, Node.js, Go), its traffic, and the team's comfort level with new tools.

Common destinations included:

  • Cloud providers: AWS, Google Cloud Platform, Microsoft Azure (for those wanting deep control and scalability)

  • Managed services: DigitalOcean, Render, Fly.io (offering a balance of control and ease of use)

  • Specialized platforms: Vercel or Netlify (for front-end heavy applications)

Each option came with its own set of advantages and challenges. What worked for a small personal blog wouldn't necessarily work for a high-traffic e-commerce site, and vice versa.

Unexpected

Discoveries and Lasting Lessons

The Heroku exodus, while challenging, led to many positive outcomes. Developers gained a much clearer picture of their infrastructure costs and learned how to optimize them. They also discovered new tools and workflows that made their deployments more efficient.

Perhaps the biggest lesson was the importance of understanding the underlying technology. Relying too heavily on a single platform, no matter how easy, could lead to problems when that platform changes. The experience taught many the value of *platform independence

  • and having a backup plan.

This period of change showed the incredible adaptability of the developer community. Faced with a major shift, they collectively found new paths, learned new skills, and built a stronger, more diverse ecosystem for web applications. The cloud continues to change, but the lessons from this big move remain relevant for anyone building online.

How does this make you feel?

Comments

0/2000

Loading comments...